Nick Thorpe Director, MENA
Clearly the “print is dead v print is very much alive” debate rages on here in the Gulf. Last week’s post by Inzy sparked a deluge of responses to the Majlis inbox, ranging from supportive to downright aghast. If anyone wants to put e-pen to e-paper with their views, hit reply. |
This week Katy Gillett examines the recent Michelin controversy in the GCC, which caused a rare crisis for an otherwise venerable and seemingly bulletproof brand. More like this please! Send your OpEd pitches to me at nick.thorpe@roxhillmedia.com |
Katy Gillett
What Michelin has taught us about the UAE’s media industry
You probably already know this, since it was kind of a big deal, but just in case, for the people in the back: when Michelin recently announced its Dubai 2026 guide, it included 16 restaurants that have closed. Some perhaps temporarily; others no one knows whether they’ll reopen. That’s more than 10 percent of the whole guide.
Now, Michelin has said – after it was specifically asked – it was “fully aware” that they were closed and “remains in close contact with their teams, monitoring when they might reopen in the near future”.
Let’s ignore the fact that a fully digital guide is telling readers to go to restaurants that no longer exist. What interests me is how the media treated it (or didn’t), and how it’s become a story of mainstream versus indie.
While the country’s major publications were covering the event and reporting on awardees, the first to flag discrepancies on social media and demand a comment from Michelin was Samantha Wood, aka the FooDiva, aka “the restaurant whisperer”, one of Dubai’s longest-serving independent restaurant critics.
After her intervention, things went viral – The National credited Wood for the scoop, as did Semafor and even the UK’s Sunday Times covered the debacle, quoting her.
Since then, the episode has been discussed – on Dubai Eye, for example, and on The National’s Culture Bites podcast – and some mainstream voices have called it an act of “grace” from Michelin that allowed these restaurants to retain their stars.
Meanwhile, the Substack writers, the newsletter authors and solo voices who have built their reputations on the absence of institutional ties have written – and spoken – about the situation with directness. Wood was quoted saying the whole thing was “incredibly shocking … and very sad”. Another food critic, Liam Collens, told The Times: “I mean, the chefs didn’t even collect the awards on the night, because some of them don’t live here anymore.” Food Sheikh also weighed in on social media, creating a new category for the guide: Bib Fermé.
The dust has now settled, and while people will surely remember that Michelin awarded stars to restaurants that were closed, I think they’ll also remember something else: who was upfront about it.
This also goes to show the growing clout of the UAE’s independent media which has been expanding for years, particularly in food writing. Some say the media industry is in freefall – well, I say the country’s indie scene is positively booming.
While the standard analysis of growth focuses on reach (subscriber numbers; whether they match the distribution of a national title; whether advertisers will follow), these days, you should not underestimate the influence of an authentic voice and the reader trust that follows.
Wood’s newsletter climbed to #22 globally on Substack under the ‘Rising’ ranking in Food & Drink, the highest she’s ever achieved. Does that mean she’s got the same hard numbers as the nationals? Of course not. But does that mean she’s won immeasurable influence? Undoubtedly.
Recent media moves
ITP has brought Nikhil Pereira back after a five-year absence, and he is now Group Editor, Supply Chain for Aviation Business Middle East , Logistics Middle East, and Retail Management Middle East. Josh Craddock, founder of JCRADS & Partners, has launched STACK Hospitality – a new digital trade publication focused on the Gulf hospitality industry. More here. Yashna Balwanth has joined identity Magazine as Editor. She was previously Lifestyle Editor at Dentsu Creative in South Africa. Yousra Zaki has been promoted to Editorial Director across Time Out GCC’s titles. Ahmad Almiqdadi has joined Altaghier TV as an Economic News Journalist in Jordan. Ramy El-Bergamy has left his role as Senior Executive Producer at MONIIFY. Al Bayan Newspaper has appointed Nada Maatar as a Journalist. |
Reading list
Samantha Wood’s opinion piece on the whole Michelin saga: [FOODIVA]
A report on how Michelin used AI to write its Dallas guide: [The D Magazine]
An older piece on a suspected lack of inspectors at Michelin: [The Guardian]
More on the growing backlash to Michelin: [delish]



