Home Roxstars Too much good is bad

Too much good is bad

Share on email
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

When the Head of Travel at The Telegraph, the fabulous Claire Irvin, asked me to write a spa column, her one stipulation was that I wasn’t too nice. She wanted to shake me out of magazine mode and into newspaper mode.

What do I mean by that? Well at magazines, I, and I think many of my colleagues, usually avoid being hyper critical, or even critical, of clothes, products, hotels or spas. The general vibe of a glossy is that it should be a relaxed read that doesn’t feel too shouty or angry. More celebratory. So if a product is less than effective, an item of clothing a bit drab, a hotel or spa sub par, we just won’t feature it.

I am generally an effusive, positive person, so my reports tend to find the good in situations, (except Kanye’s bid for president – I can’t find any plus points in that), so my reviews tend to mirror that.

But I recognise that people want a balanced view from their newspaper. If it’s all positive it feels like a paid promotion. The readers have an BS radar that means they immediately glaze over if a story feels bought. I’ve seen and heard this in reader panels a million times. Okay not a million, but a fair few.

Yes, yes, you might say, but how does this impact me? Well I guess it’s about managing your client’s expectations. Saying that yes, a journalist might have pointed out the spa menu was lacking imagination, or that the product’s pump was faulty, but if it’s a fair and balanced review, it’s better than a tap-dancing puff piece which has zero credibility.

Subscribe

Tomorrow's Business
Roxstars

Roxhill updates

Click below to choose which updates your receive.



post
post

Previous
If you can’t be nice…

Roxstars

Next
The importance of feeding tit-bits

post
post

Similar Posts

Other Posts by

We use cookies to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Accept cookie settings by clicking the button.
You can view our Cookie Policy or Privacy Policy.